Social workers in Calgary counsel a homeless man
HELPING THE HOMELESS HURTS. This truth is revealed in a recent study by Professor Jeannette Waegemakers-Schiff at the University of Alberta.
Waegemakers-Schiff conducted interviews with 470 frontline workers at 23 organizatons and agencies working with the homeless in Calgary. She found that:
- 33% of frontline support workers who work with the homeless suffer from PTSD—a rate more than double the rates found among frontline first responders like paramedics, firefighters, and nurses
- 24% of the workers with the homeless suffer levels of burnout and vicarious trauma sufficient to justify them taking leave from their jobs
- the problems faced by homeless people and support staff have become much more complex over recent years.
Drug use makes everything worse
“When I first joined the agency there was no expectation of responding to overdoses. Over the years, it was something that had to be learned … we weren’t prepared,” said Jeff Schoen, who has worked with the homeless for 11 years. “I myself have responded to more overdoses than I can count, and it never gets easier.”
Many workers are not trained to deal with the personal and social challenges faced by homeless people.
The study found that 60% of frontline workers entered the profession with less than two years of post-secondary education. This, in turn, is linked to another troubling fact uncovered by the study: over 70% of respondents earn less than $50,000 annually.
“Frontline work is not entry-level work, even though it’s perceived that way and funded that way. It takes a tremendous amount of skill to deal with situations effectively and in the moment,” explained Sandra Clarkson, executive director of a drop-in centre in Calgary.
An additional factor driving the high rates of PTSD among frontline workers is the close relationships they develop with their clients. “They see the discrimination, they see the things the families encounter that is preventing them from moving on with their lives, and there’s a personal investment there,” said Louise Gallagher, executive director of the homeless support service In From the Cold.
Chronic underfunding from successive provincial and federal governments is at the root of these problems. Clarkson points out demand for her centre’s services has increased steadily for ten years, while funding from the province has not.
Inadequate budgets mean that shelters and other support centres are forced to rely on inexperienced personnel. For example, 43% of respondents in the study said they have been in their jobs for less than two years, while fully three quarters had less than five years of work experience.
In a 2016 study Waegemakers-Schiff pointed to a shortage of addiction councillors. “Even when those with a university degree are factored into this picture, most do not come to their positions with training in interview, counselling or intervention skills.
“Further, while addictions is a major issue for homeless persons, there are virtually no addictions counsellors among our respondents and thus there appears to be a serious lack of attention to the special interventions that are required for many homeless persons who also struggle with addictions.”
Improving the crisis conditions confronting support workers with the homeless, and with the homeless themselves, requires significantly more investment by government. It is only with adequate funding that workers with the necessary skills can be hired, employees compensated fairly, and workers provided with necessary training and support.
However, Waegemakers-Schiff also points out that simple policy changes could make things a lot easier for frontline support workers. “They can’t take a mental health day, or take time off because its frowned upon,” she said.
“There aren’t policies in any of these agencies that allow workers to take paid leave after a bad experience—the way that police or firefighters would for example.”
This needs to be part of a “root shift in organizational culture” focused on practices to deal with high stress levels of staff, adds Waegemakers-Schiff.
The high rates of mental health hazards for workers with the homeless is a serious problem that must be acknowledged and remedied. But the deeper problem is homelessness itself. The real lasting remedy, for the frontline workers and the homeless, would be ending homelessness.
We will only achieve this once our governments add decent and affordable housing, accessible to all, to our Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms.
- 30 -